Home • PRRES Inc. Journal • Read the Journal

Impact of Contaminated Land Adjoining the New Disney Theme Park in Hong Kong

Author/s: Nelson Chan

Date Published: 1/01/2003

Published in: Volume 9 - 2003 Issue 3 (pages 265 - 280)

Abstract

As a measure to boost the economy, the Hong Kong Special Administration Region government (HKSAR government) reached an agreement in November 1999 with Walt Disney to build a 126-hectare theme park on Lantau Island in the former British Colony. In connection with the construction of roads and other infrastructure for the future park, a shipyard was compulsorily acquired by the government. It was later found that the demolition of the shipyard would involve the removal of around 87,000 cubic metres of dioxin laden contaminated soil. The presence of the highly toxic soil required extra finance for the remediation. It not only caused a budget blowout but also an embarrassment to the HKSAR government. This paper finds that the problems were mainly caused by the fragmented nature of the current contaminated land management approach adopted by the government and the lack of adequate power for the acquiring authority to enter the land for site investigation prior to the land acquisition. Unless appropriate changes are made to the current land contamination management and land acquisition practice, similar land contamination incidents may occur in the future and may have a long-term impact on the Hong Kong property market.

Download Full Article

Download the Full Article PDF

14445921.2003.11104143.pdf 14445921.2003.11104143.pdf (210kB)

Keywords

Dioxin - Disney Theme Park - Environmental Protection - Remediation

References

  • Agence France-Press. (2002), Greenpeace Slams HK Government and Disney Plan to Dispose of Dioxins, 19 April, http://www.softcom.net/webnews/wed/ax/Qhongkong-environment. RtOC CAJ.html.
  • Bond, S. (2000), Do Market Perceptions Affect Market Prices? A Case Study of a Remediated Contaminated Site, Research paper presented at the 16 American Real Estate Society Conference, Santa Barbara, California, 29 March -1 April.
  • Chan, N. (1997), Land Contamination Law -The Overseas Experience, The Valuer & Land Economist, Vol. 34, No. 7, pp. 644-648.
  • Chan, N. (1999), Land-Use Rights in Mainland China: Problems and Recommendation for Improvement, Journal of Real Estate Literature, Vol. 7, No. 1, pp. 53-63.
  • Chan, N. (2001), Stigma And Its Assessment Methods, Pacific Rim Property Research Journal, Vol. 7, No. 2, pp. 126-140.
  • Chan, N. (2002), Stigma Assessment: A Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Approach, Pacific Rim Property Research Journal, Vol. 8, No. 1, pp. 29-47.
  • Chan, N., Jefferies, R. & Simons, R. (1998), Government Regulation of Contaminated Land - A Tale of Three Cities, Environmental And Planning Law Journal, Vol. 15, No. 5, pp. 321-337.
  • Cruden, G. (1986), Land Compensation and Valuation Law in Hong Kong, Butterworths, Singapore.
  • Dioxin Homepage, (c.1998), Dioxin Articles, http://www.ejnet.org/dioxin/, 27 July 2002.
  • Egerton, L. (1990), Do It Yourself Earth Repair An Australian Guide Towards Better Planet Habits, Australia: Reed Books Pty Ltd.
  • Environmental Protection Department, Hong Kong Special Administrative Region (EPD HKSAR). (2002), Summary of Environmental Legislation, http://www.info.gov.hk/epd/english/laws_regulations/envir_legislation/laws_ovrview.html.
  • Forest Conservation Portal. (2002), Disney Site Poses Ecological Threat -Experts, http://forests.org/articles/reader.asp?linkid=8073, 26 July 2002.
  • Fung, B. Y. (2001), A Century of Hong Kong Real Estate Development, Joint Publishing (HK) Ltd.
  • Hong Kong Disneyland, 2002, Fact Sheet, http://www.disney.com.hk/hkdisneyland/english/fact_sheet.html.
  • Information Services Department, Hong Kong Special Administration Region Government (ISD HKSARG). (2000), Rail Shuttle to Hong Kong Disneyland, Press Release, 21 July.
  • Information Services Department, Hong Kong Special Administration Region Government (ISD HKSARG). (2002), Hong Kong Disneyland - An Asset For The Future, http://www.info.gov.hk/Disneyland/en.htm.
  • Information Services Department, Hong Kong Special Administration Region Government (ISD HKSARG). (2003), Hong Kong in Brief, http://www.info.gov.hk/hkbrief/ahke.htm.
  • Leung, K.L., General Manager, Property Planning Department, Henderson Land Development Co. Ltd., 21 November 2002.
  • Mak, M.L.S., Head of Community Relation Unit, Environmental Protection Department, Hong Kong, interview, 19 November 2002.
  • Mak, M.T.S., Senior Estate Surveyor, Lands Department, Hong Kong, interview, 20 November 2002.
  • Maunsell Consultants Asia Ltd (MCAL). 2002, Infrastructure for Penney’s Bay Development Engineering Design and Construction, Decommissioning of Cheoy Lee Shipyard At Penney’s Bay, EIA - Final Report, Executive Summary.
  • Mingpao News. (2002), Disney selected site contains carcinogenic dioxin, http://full.mingpaonws.com/20020222/gaa1hr.htm, 22 February 2002.
  • Mundy, B. (1992), Stigma and Value, The Appraisal Journal, LX (1), pp. 7-13.
  • Neustein, R. & Bell, R. (1998), Diminishing Diminution: A Trend in Environmental Stigma, Environmental Claims Journal, 11(1), pp. 47- 59.
  • Ng, A., Assistant Director of Planning, Planning Department, Hong Kong, interview, 20 November 2002.
  • Patchin, P. (1991), Contaminated Properties - Stigma Revisited, The Appraisal Journal, LIX (2), pp. 167-172.
  • Pearce, F. (1992), Sitting on a toxic time bomb, New Scientist, 15 August, pp. 1213.
  • Rating and Valuation Department, Hong Kong Special Administration Region Government (R&VD HKSAR). (2003), Price Indices for Hong Kong Property Market http://www.info.gov.hk/rvd/property/pdf/graph2.pdf
  • Reuters. (2002), HK Disney site poses ecological threat, 22 February, http://forests.org/articles /reader.asp?linkid=8073, 26 July 2002.
  • Roddewig, R. (1996), Stigma, Environmental Risk and Property Value: 10 Critical Inquiries, The Appraisal Journal, LXIV (4), pp. 375-387.
  • Syms, P. (1997), Perceptions of Risk in the Valuation of Contaminated Land, Journal of Property Valuation & Investment, 15 (1), pp. 27-39.
  • Tsing, M.M.K., Senior Environmental Protection Officer, Environmental Protection Department, Hong Kong, interview, 19 November 2002.