Home • PRRES Inc. Journal • Read the Journal

The economic value of low-energy housing

Author/s: Hao Wu, Robert H. Crawford, Georgia Warren-Myers, Malay Dave, Masa Noguchi

Date Published: 2/01/2016

Published in: Volume 22 - 2016 Issue 1 (pages 45 - 58)

Abstract

This paper explores a new perspective towards understanding barriers to ascertaining the economic value of low-energy housing. It examines why the economic value of low-energy housing is less transparent in active markets; this is investigated from the valuation principle perspectives of embodied energy and operational energy in residential dwellings. The focus is placed on the composition of energy consumption associated with the housing product life cycle. Low operational energy of a dwelling is linked to consumer preference by the inter-temporal value estimate of expected benefits. However, “low” embodied energy housing is an ecological construct and does not appear to be directly linked to short-term market value or an expected (intuitive) economic motive. This “gap/disconnect”, alongside some practical “barriers” in the market economy, has created a challenge in deriving the economic value of low-energy housing. The barrier to economic value of low-energy housing is methodological and by adopting a life cycle approach to assessing and measuring energy in a house that incorporates embodied energy and operational energy, greater clarity can be achieved which may lead to a better informed market, enhancing transparency and allowing consumer choice to direct and value the broader benefits of low-energy housing.

Download Full Article

Download the Full Article PDF

14445921.2016.1161869.pdf 14445921.2016.1161869.pdf (846kB)

Keywords

Economic Value - Embodied Energy (Ee) - Low-Energy Housing - Operational Energy (Ope)

References

  • Adan, H.Fuerst, F. (2015) Do energy efficiency measures really reduce household energy consumption? A difference-in-difference analysis, Energy Efficiency. p:1-13. Energy Efficiency.
  • Aelenei, L.Aelenei, D.Gonçalves, H.Lollini, R.Musall, E.Scognamiglio, A.Noguchi, M. (2013) Design issues for net zero-energy buildings, Open House International. 38, p:7-14. Open House International.
  • Ball, M. (2003) Is there an office replacement cycle?, Journal of Property Research. 20, –.p:173-189. Journal of Property Research.
  • Baum, A. (1991) Property investment, depreciation and obsolescence. London:Routledge. Property investment, depreciation and obsolescence.
  • Chen, T. Y.Burnett, J.Chau, C. K. (2001) Analysis of embodied energy use in the residential building of Hong Kong, Energy. 26, p:323-340. Energy.
  • Cochrane, J. H. (2011) Discount rates, The Journal of Finance. 66, –.p:1047-1108. The Journal of Finance.
  • Cole, J. R. (2015) Net-zero and net-positive design: A question of value, Building Research & Information. 43(1), –.p:1-6. Building Research & Information.
  • Cole, R. J.Fedoruk, L. (2015) Shifting from net-zero to net-positive buildings, Building Research and Information. 43, p:111-120. Building Research and Information.
  • Costanza, R. (1980) Embodied energy and economic valuation, Science. 210, –.p:1219-1224. Science.
  • Costanza, R.Herendeen, R. A. (1984) Embodied energy and economic value in the United States economy: 1963, 1967 and 1972, Resources and Energy. 6, p:129-163. Resources and Energy.
  • Crawford, R. H. (2011a) Towards a comprehensive approach to zero-emissions housing, Architectural Science Review. 54, –.p:277-284. Architectural Science Review.
  • Crawford, R. H. (2011b) Life cycle assessment in the built environment, Sydney:Taylor and Francis.
  • Dave, M. (2014) Chasing ZED – Once the holy grail, but are ‘zero carbon’ homes enough?, How to rethink building materials: Creating ecological housing for the designer, builder and homeowner. Sydney: In (Ed.), (pp. –)p:80-81. CL Creations. How to rethink building materials: Creating ecological housing for the designer, builder and homeowner.
  • DEWHA. (2008) Energy efficiency rating and house price in ACT. Canberra:Department of the Environment, Water, Heritage and the Arts, Australian Government. Energy efficiency rating and house price in ACT.
  • Farber, S. C.Costanza, R.Wilson, M. A. (2002) Economic and ecological concepts for valuing ecosystem services, Ecological Economics. 41, p:375-392. Ecological Economics.
  • Fuerst, F.McAllister, P.Nanda, A.Wyatt, P. (2015) Variations in the implicit pricing of energy performance by dwelling type and tenure: A study of Wales, Retrieved from SSRN:http://ssrn.com/abstract=2633539
  • Georges, L.Haase, M.Wiberg, A.Kristjansdottir, T.Risholt, B. (2015) Life cycle emissions analysis of two nZEB concepts, Building Research and Information. 43, p:82-93. Building Research and Information.
  • Giglio, S.Maggiori, M.Stroebel, J. (2014) Very long run discount rates, New York: p:1-29. NBER Working Paper Series, w20133.
  • Hamilton, G.Summerfield, J.Steadman, P.Stone, A.Davies, M. (2010) Exploring energy integration between new and existing developments, Building Research and Information. 38, p:593-609. Building Research and Information.
  • Hornborg, A. (1998) Towards an ecological theory of unequal exchange: Articulating world system theory and ecological economics, Ecological Economics. 25, –.p:127-136. Ecological Economics.
  • Huettner, D. A.Costanza, R. (1982) Economic value and embodied energy, Science. 216, p:1141-1143. Science.
  • Japan Prefabricated Construction and Suppliers and Manufacturers Association. (2008). Retrieved March 13, 2008, fromPrefab club. Retrieved from http://www.purekyo.or.jp/3-1.html
  • Keynes, J. M. (1936) The general theory of employment, interest and money. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press. The general theory of employment, interest and money.
  • Lutzkendorf, T.Follente, G.Balouktsi, M.Wiberg, A. (2015) Net-zero buildings: Incorporating embodied impacts, Building Research and Information. 43, p:62-81. Building Research and Information.
  • Mang, P.Reed, B. (2015) The nature of positive, Building Research & Information. 43, p:7-10. Building Research & Information.
  • Neo, P. H.Ong, S. E.Tu, Y. (2008) Buyer exuberance and price premium, Urban Studies. 45, p:331-345. Urban Studies.
  • Noguchi, M. (2008) Editorial: The quest for zero carbon housing solutions, Open House International. 33, –.p:88-95. Open House International.
  • Noguchi, M. (2011) Enhancement of industry initiative through the zero-energy mass custom home mission to Japan experience towards commercialisation, International Journal of Mass Customisation. 4, –.p:106-121. International Journal of Mass Customisation.
  • Noguchi, M. (2013) Commercialization principles for the low-carbon mass customized housing delivery in Japan, Mass-customisation & personalisation in architecture and construction. London: In (Eds.), (pp. –)p:164-173. Routledge Architecture. Mass-customisation & personalisation in architecture and construction.
  • Noguchi, M.Collins, D. (2008) Commercialisation strategies for net zero-energy-cost housing in Japan, Open House International. 33, p:96-104. Open House International.
  • Pan, W.Ning, Y. (2015) A socio-technical framework of zero-carbon building policies, Building Research and Information. 43, p:94-110. Building Research and Information.
  • Pearce, D. (1993) Economic value and the natural world. London:Earthscan. Economic value and the natural world.
  • Sekisui Chemical Co., & Ltd. (2004a) 2?×?6 grand to you; Technology Catalog. Tokyo:Author. 2?×?6 grand to you; Technology Catalog.
  • Sekisui Chemical Co., & Ltd. (2004) Annual report 2004. Tokyo:Author. Annual report 2004.
  • Tobin, J.Brainard, W. C. (1976) Asset markets and the cost of capital, p:1-45. Cowles Foundation Discussion Paper, #427.
  • Treloar, G. J. (1997) Extracting embodied energy paths from input–output tables: Towards an input–output-based hybrid energy analysis method, Economic Systems Research. 9, –.p:375-391. Economic Systems Research.
  • Treloar, G. J.Love, P. E.Faniran, O.Raniga, U. I. (2000) A hybrid life cycle assessment method for construction, Construction Management and Economics. 18, p:5-9. Construction Management and Economics.
  • Treloar, G.Love, P.Holt, G. (2001) Using national input–output data for embodied energy analysis of individual residential buildings, Construction Management and Economics. 19, p:49-61. Construction Management and Economics.
  • Warren-Myers, G. (2012) The value of sustainability in real estate: A review from a valuation perspective, Journal of Property Investment & Finance. 30, –.p:115-144. Journal of Property Investment & Finance.
  • Warren-Myers, G. (2013) Is the valuer the barrier to identifying the value of sustainability?, Journal of Property Investment & Finance. 31, –.p:345-359. Journal of Property Investment & Finance.
  • Whipple, T. (2006) Property valuation and analysis. (2nd ed. ed.). Sydney.LawBook. Property valuation and analysis.
  • Wong, S. K.Chau, K. W.Yiu, C. Y.Yu, M. K. W. (2008) Intergenerational discounting: A case from Hong Kong, Habitat International. 32, p:283-292. Habitat International.