Home • PRRES Inc. Journal • Read the Journal

Valuing Sustainability in Australia: Implications for the Valuation Profession

Author/s: Georgia Warren-Myers

Date Published: 1/01/2012

Published in: Volume 18 - 2012 Issue 2 (pages 163 - 179)

Abstract

There is an urgent need for sustainability to be incorporated into the valuation process in order to ascertain and accurately reflect the relationship between sustainability and market value, and increase large-scale sustainability investment in property. This predicament has been recognised and increasing emphasis from industry, valuation bodies and academia is being placed on valuers to incorporate sustainability into the valuation process. However, it is questionable whether valuers are adequately equipped with the knowledge and skills to incorporate sustainability into valuation practice. This research investigates valuers’ incorporation of sustainability in valuation practice and their knowledge of sustainability. It is anticipated that with the increasing need to report on sustainability, valuers’ knowledge levels will need to develop. Warren-Myers (2010) found valuers at the time (in 2008) were inadequately skilled to incorporate sustainability into value assessments. The fundamental process of valuation practice is a complex relationship between art and science, and the building of strategic knowledge to develop the heuristics and judgement required in valuation takes time. This research endeavours to track valuers’ sustainability knowledge development in Australia over time and will, consequently, lead valuers’ to be more th orough in their comparative analysis and assessment of sustainability factors in property. The identification of a clearer relationship between sustainability and market value should result. The research method utilises a mixed-mode approach, using surveys built of open and closed questions that investigate valuers’ perceptions of their own knowledge, their actions in practice, and tests their knowledge of sustainability. This paper presents the findings from the first phase of this research project. The research found valuers in Australia are reporting on sustainability in valuation reports, and providing advice to clients on sustainability. However, it has also found that valuers are reliant on sustainability assessment tools, about which they have only limited knowledge. Compared to previous research where valuers were reluctant to address sustainability in valuation practice, this research has found a demonstrable change in the profession. However, there is cause for concern considering the level of knowledge and understanding valuers are displaying. Long-term, their lack of knowledge may cause more issues with the misapplication or judgements made in valuation regarding the relationship between sustainability and value. This research stresses the implications for the profession, should valuers be reporting and advising on concepts of which they have limited understanding, and should they be adapting or making judgements about sustainability in the valuation process, which ultimately affects the reporting of market value. This research highlights the urgent need for professional development in the property industry and, in particular, for valuers to develop their knowledge, understanding, assessment capabilities and judgement of sustainability in valuation practice.

Download Full Article

Download the Full Article PDF

14445921.2012.11104357.pdf 14445921.2012.11104357.pdf (1MB)

Keywords

Sustainability - Valuation - Valuation Practice

References

  • Adair, A, Berry, J, and McGreal, S 1996, ‘Valuation of residential property: analysis of participant behaviour’, Journal of Property Valuation and Investment, Vol. 14, No. 1, pp.20 - 35
  • Australian Building Codes Board 2012, http://www.abcb.gov.au/ (access 24 May 2012)
  • Australian Government 2012, Commercial building disclosure: A national energy efficiency scheme, Australian Government, http://www.cbd.gov.au/ (accessed 24 May 2012)
  • Australian Greenhouse Office 2000, Energy research for the Building Code of Australia, Australian Greenhouse Office, Canberra ACT
  • Bowman, R and Wills, J 2008, Valuing green: how green buildings affect property values and getting the valuation method right, Australian Green Building Council, Melbourne
  • Commonwealth of Australia 2012, Nationwide house energy rating scheme, http://www.nathers.gov.au/ (accessed 24 May 2012)
  • CBRE 2011, Valuing sustainable building: green assets, the role of professional valuers, and assembling an evidence base, Q3 2011 View point, CBRE, London
  • Diaz, J 1999, ‘The first decade of behavioral research in the discipline of property’, Journal of Property Investment and Finance, Vol. 17, No. 4, pp.326 - 332
  • Duggan, W 2007, Strategic intuition: the creative spark in human achievement, Columbia University Press, Chichester, West Sussex
  • Eichholtz, P, Kok, N and Quigley, JM 2009, Doing well by doing good? green office buildings, RICS Research, March 2009, Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors, London
  • Eichholtz, P, Kok, N and Quigley, JM 2010, Sustainability and the dynamics of green - new evidence on the financial performance of green office buildings in the USA, Research Report, August, Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors, London
  • Fuerst, F and McAllister, P 2008a, Green noise or green value? Measuring the price effects of environmental certification in commercial buildings, School of Real Estate and Planning, Henley Business School, University of Reading, Reading,http:// papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfmabstract id=1140409 (Accessed 12 November 2011)
  • Fuerst, F and McAllister, P 2008b, Pricing sustainability: an empirical investigation of the value impacts of green building certification, Working Paper from the Proceedings of the American Real Estate Society Conference, April 2008, Florida
  • Fuerst, F and McAllister, P 2010, What is the effect of eco-labelling on office occupancy rates in the USA?RICS Fibre Series, January, Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors, London.
  • Gallimore, P 1996, ‘Confirmation bias in the valuation process: a test for corroborating evidence’, Journal of Property Research, Vol. 13, No. 4, pp. 261 - 273
  • Gladwell, M 2005, Blink: the power of thinking without thinking, Allen Lane, Maryborough, Victoria, Australia
  • Green Building Council Australia 2012, Green star overview, Green Building Council of Australiahttp://www.gbca.org.au/green-star/green-star-overview/ (accessed 24 May 2012).
  • Henley, J 2011, Green star New Zealand 5 year anniversary, CEO of the World Green Building Council, [presentation] (Personal communication 11 November 2011)
  • IPD 2012, PCA/IPD Green quarterly property investment index, http://www 1.ipd.com/Pages/default.aspx (accessed 24 May 2012)
  • International Valuation Standards Committee 2007, International valuation standards, International Valuation Standards Committee, London
  • Lorenz, D 2008, Breaking the vicious circle of blame, RICS FiBRE Findings in Built and Rural Environments, Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors, June 2008, London
  • Lorenz, D and Lutzkendorf, T 2008, ‘Sustainability in property valuation - theory and practice’, Journal of Property Investment and Finance, Vol. 26, No. 6, pp. 482–521
  • Lorenz, D and Lutzkendorf, T 2011,’Sustainability and property valuation - systematisation of existing approaches and recommendations for future action’, Journal of Property Investment and Finance, Vol. 29, No. 6, pp. 644–676
  • Lutzkendorf, T and Lorenz, D 2005, ‘Sustainable property investment: valuing sustainable buildings through property performance assessment’, Building Research and Information, Vol. 33, No. 3, pp. 212–234
  • Lutzkendorf, T and Lorenz, D 2011, ‘Capturing sustainability-related information for property valuation’, Building Research and Information, Vol. 39, No. 3, pp. 256–273
  • Mallinson, M and French, N 2000, ‘Uncertainty in property valuation - the nature and relevance of uncertainty and how it might be measured and reported’, Journal of Property Investment and Finance, Vol. 18, No. 1, pp.13 - 32
  • McColl-Kennedy, JR and Kiel, GC 2000, Marketing: a strategic approach, Nelson Thomson Learning, South Melbourne
  • McColl-Kennedy, JR, Kiel, GC, Lussch, RF and Lussch, VN 1992, Marketing: concepts and strategies, Thomas Nelson, MacArthur Press, South Melbourne
  • Muldavin, S 2009, Ten principles for sustainable property underwriting and valuation, RICS Property World, Fall
  • Muldavin, S 2010, Value beyond cost savings: how to underwrite sustainable properties, Green Building Finance Consortium, San Rafael
  • Newell, G, MacFarlane, J and Kok, N 2011, Building better returns: a study of the financial performance of green office building in Australia, University of Western Sydney, Australia, and University of Maastricht, Netherlands, Australian Property Institute and Property Funds Australia, Sydney, Australia
  • NSW Government 2012, National Australian built environment rating system (NABEflS),http://www.nabers.com.au/ (accessed 24 May 2012)
  • NSW Government 2012a, Building sustainability index (BASIX) https://www.basix.nsw.gov.au/information/about.jsp (accessed 24 May 2012)
  • Peto, R, French, N and Bowman, G 1996, ‘PRACTICE PAPER: Price and worth developments in valuation methodology’, Journal of Property Valuation and Investment, Vol. 14, No. 4, pp. 79 - 100
  • Pivo, G and Fisher, JD 2009, Investment returns from responsible property investments: energy efficient, transit-orientated and urban regeneration office properties in the US from 1998 2008, Working Paper, Responsible Property Investing Center, Boston College and University of Arizona Benecki Center for Real Estate Studies, Boston
  • Pivo, G and Fisher, JD 2010, ‘Income, value, and returns in socially responsible office properties’, Journal of Real Estate Research, Vol. 32, No. 3, pp. 243–270
  • Property Council of Australia 2006, A guide of office building quality, Property Council of Australia, Sydney
  • RICS 2009, Sustainability and commercial property valuation, RICS Valuation Information Paper No. 13, Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors, London, 15 September 2009
  • RICS 2011, Sustainability and the valuation of commercial property (Australia), Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors, Sydney, August 2011
  • Sayce, S, Sundberg, A and Clements, B 2010, Is sustainability reflected in commercial property prices?: an analysis of the evidence base, RICS Research Report, January 2010, Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors, London
  • UNEP 2011, Buildings: investing in energy and resource efficiency, United Nations Environment Programme, 2011 http://www.unep.org/greeneconomy/ accessed 16 February 2012
  • Warren-Myers, G 2010, Valuation practice issues in commercial property: the relationship between sustainability and market value, unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Melbourne, Australia
  • Warren-Myers, G 2011, ‘Sustainability - the crucial challenge for the valuation profession’, Pacific Rim Real Estate Journal, December 2011
  • Warren-Myers, G 2011a, ‘Valuing sustainability - a challenge for the profession’, Australian and New Zealand Property Journal, September 2011, Australia
  • Warren-Myers, G 2012, ‘The value of sustainability in real estate: a review from a valuation perspective’, Journal of Property Investment and Finance, Vol. 30, No. 2
  • Warren-Myers, G 2012a, ‘Is sustainability in the commercial property industry just best practice management?’, in N M’Sirdi, A Namaane, RJ Howlett and LC Jain (Eds) Sustainability in energy and buildings: proceedings of the 3rd international conference on sustainability in energy and buildings (SEB11), Springer-Verlag, Berlin
  • Warren-Myers, G and Reed, R 2010, ‘Identifying and examining links between sustainability and value: evidence from Australia and New Zealand’, Journal of Sustainable Real Estate, Vol. 2