Home • PRRES Inc. Journal • Read the Journal

Developing a Compensation Framework for the Acquisition of Orang Asli Native Lands in Malaysia: The Professionals’ Perceptions

Author/s: Anuar Alias, M D Nasir Daud

Date Published: 1/01/2009

Published in: Volume 15 - 2009 Issue 1 (pages 36 - 67)

Abstract

This research explores the issues of land rights and land acquisition compensation related to the Orang Asli (the Malay term for indigenous peoples) in Peninsular Malaysia. Acquisition of Orang Asli native lands is inevitable as land is scarce to meet the national growth agenda and socio-economic developments. As an independent country, Malaysia provides constitutional guarantees, and customary land tenure is recognised and respected. Unfortunately, due to the ambiguity in Malaysian legal system in relation to the definition of land rights of Orang Asli native lands, the practice of payment of compensation to acquisition of the land tends to be unstructured, and disparity exists among the different states. It is therefore pertinent to propose a uniform compensation framework for the acquisition of Orang Asli native lands. This research adopts a questionnaire survey as the method of study, the descriptive and inferential analysis technique to present the results. The study showed that laws of Malaysia are deficient with regard to the protection of Orang Asli lands and rights to fair and just compensation. This research found that the position of Orang Asli land rights has not improved much. Due to this unresolved land rights issue, the present structure of compensation as spelt out under Sections 11 and 12 of the Aboriginal Peoples Act 1954 is perceived as inadequate. As currently practised, in the absence of proper guidelines and regulations, the determination of compensation is entirely at the discretion of the various authorities. Some authorities apply the legislation rigidly, while others are too generous. This research also led to the recommendation that the compensation framework for land acquisition of Orang Asli native lands should possess two categories of compensation -monetary and non-monetary components.

Download Full Article

Download the Full Article PDF

14445921.2009.11104271.pdf 14445921.2009.11104271.pdf (382kB)

Keywords

Adequate Compensation - Compensation Framework - Land Acquisition - Orang Asli Land Rights

References

  • Altman, J. and Smith, D.E. (1994). ‘The Economic Impact of Mining Moneys: The Nabarlek Case, Western Arnhem Lanc F, CAEPR Discussion Paper No. 63, CAEPR, ANU, Canberra.
  • Adong Kuwau, (1997), Adong bin Kuwau and Ors v Kerajaan Negeri Johor and Anor, [1997] 1 MLJ 418, Kuala Lumpur: Malaysian Law Journal.
  • Awang, Y., (1996), Isu-Isu dan Masa Depan Tanah Masyarakat Orang Asli Semenanjung Malaysia, Paper presented at the National Conference On Pan-Malaysia Indigenous Peoples alnd Rights and Cultural Identity at Uinversity Malaya from 2 to 3 September 1996.
  • Boydell S., (2001), Land Tenure and Land Conflict in the South Pacific, Consultancy Report for the Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO) of the United Nation, Suva, Fiji: USP Solutions, September 2001.
  • Chase, A.K., (1980), Which Way Now? Tradition, Continuity and Change in North Queensland Aboriginal Community, Unpublished PhD Thesis, Department of Anthropology and Sociology, University of Queensland, Brisbane.
  • Cheah, W.L., (2004a), Sagong Tasi and Orang Asli Land Rights in Malaysia: Victory, Milestone or False Start?, Law, Social Justice & Global Development Journal (LGD), 2004(2).
  • Cheah W.L., (2004b), Sagong Tasi: Reconciling State Development and Orang Asli Rights in Malaysia Courts, ARI Working Paper No. 25, Asia Research Institute, Singapore.
  • Dollah, R., (1996), Orang Asli: Tiada Tanah, Tiada Jatidiri, Diterkam Pembangunan dan Terjun ke Dalam Kemiskinan, Paper presented at the National Conference on Pan-Malaysia Indigenous Peoples and Rights and Cultural Identity at University Malaya from 2 to 3 September 1996.
  • Humphry, C., (1998), Compensation for Native Title: The Theory and Reality, Murdoch University Electronic Journal of Law, Vol. 5. No 1 (March 1998), http:www.murdoch.edu.au./elaw/issues/v5n1/humph51.html
  • Hyam, A., (1995), The Law Affecting Valuation of Land in Australia, 2 Ed, Sydney: The Law Book Co Ltd.
  • Hyam, A., (2004), The Law Affecting Valuation of Land in Australia, 3 Edition, The Federation Press.
  • Idris, J.; Salleh M.T,; Mohd Dom J.; Jawi A. H.; Shafie M. R., (1983), Planning and Administration of Development Programmes for Tribal Peoples (The Malaysian Setting), Kuala Lumpur: JHEOA.
  • Ismail, A.R., (2005), International Covenant on Economics, Social and Cultural Rights: Focusing on the Rights to Work and Related Aspects / Protection of Native Rights, 13 Malaysian Law Conference, Kuala Lumpur, 17 November 2005.
  • Jafry, M., (1996), Perundangan dan Dasar-Dasar Tanah Yang Melibatkan Hak Asasi Anak Negeri (Native Customary Right) di Sabah, Paper presented at the National Conference on Pan-Malaysia Indigenous Peoples and Rights and Cultural Identity at University Malaya from 2 to 3 September 1996.
  • Jamaludin I., (1997), Kenyataan Ketua Pengarah Jabatan Hal Ehwal Orang Asli Malaysia pada perjumpaan dengan Wakil-Wakil Media Massa pada 31 Oktober 1997, Kuala Lumpur: JHEOA.
  • JHEOA, (1996), Jabatan Hal Ehwal Orang Asli, Kementerian Luar Bandar dan Pembangunan Wilayah, Malaysia
  • JHEOA, (2006), Jabatan Hal Ehwal Orang Asli, Kementerian Luar Bandar dan Pembangunan Wilayah, Malaysia
  • Keith, D., (1984), Law of Compulsory Purchase and Compensation, 4 Ed., London: Butterworth.
  • Kickett, D., (1999), Compensation, in NNTT, ‘Compensation for Native Title: Issues and Chanllenges’, Papers from a Workshop held in 1997, NNTT, Perth.
  • Maddock, K., (1984), Aboriginal Customary Law, in P. Hanks and B. Keon-Cohen (eds), Aborigines and the Law, George Allan and Unwin, Sydney.
  • Mah, D.C.H., (1995), The National Native Title Tribunal: Compensation Issues – A Discussion Paper, Murdoch University Electronic Journal of Law, Vol. 2. No 1 (April 1995), http:www.murdoch.edu.au./elaw/issues/v2n1/mah21.html
  • Martin, D., (1995), Money, Business and Culture: Principles and Implications of Aboriginal Sharing, CAEPR Discussion Paper No. 101, CAEPR, ANU, Canberra.
  • Myers, F., (1986), Pintupi Country, Pintupi Self: Sentiment, Place and Politics among Western Desert Aborigines, Washington DC: Smithsonian Institute Press and Canberra: AIAS.
  • Nicholas, C., (2003), Suhakam Calls on Perak Government to resolve Orang Asli disputes, Bernama Malaysian News Agency, November 10, 2003; “Suhakam Report on Orang Asli basic rights ready next week” Bernama Malaysian News Agency, December 15, 2003.
  • Nik Yusof, N.M.Z., (1996), Dasar Pemilikan Tanah Oleh Orang-Orang Asli Di Semenanjung Malaysia, Paper presented at the National Conference on Pan-Malaysia Indigenous Peoples and Rights and Cultural Identity at University Malaya from 2 to 3 September 1996.
  • Peterson, N., (1991), Cash, Commodisation and Authenticity: When do Aboriginal People Stop Being Hunter-Gatherers?, Senri Ethnological Studies, Vol. 30, p.67-90.
  • Rani, H.O., (2004), Economic and Business Research for Malaysian Students, Tanjong Malim - Malaysia: Penerbit Universiti Pendidikan Sultan Idris.
  • Sagong Tasi, (2002), Sagong bin Tasi and Ors v Kerajaan Negeri Selangor and Ors, [2002] 2 MLJ 591, Kuala Lumpur: Malaysian Law Journal.
  • Sheehan, J., (1997), Indigenous Property Rights: Towards a Valuation Methodology, Paper presented at workshop ‘Compensation for Native Title: Issues and Challenges’, Organised by Australian Institute of Valuers and Land Economists and the National Native Title Tribunal, Brisbane, 18 August 1997.
  • Sheehan, J. & Small G., (2001), Towards a Definition of Property Rights, Paper presented at the Pacific Rim Real Estate Society (PRRES) Conference, Christchurch, New Zealand, 21 January 2001.
  • Salleh, M. T., (1990), An Examination of Development Planning Among the Rural Orang Asli of West Malaysia, PhD Dissertation, University of Bath. Unpublished.
  • Small, R. (1998), A Strategy for the Integration of Native Title, PRRES Conference, January 1998, Perth.
  • Smith, D. (2001), Valuing Native Title: Aboriginal, Statutory and Policy Discourse about Compensation, Discussion Paper No. 222/2001, Centre for Aboriginal Economic Policy Research, The Australian National University.
  • Suhut, M., (2006), Teks Ucapan Presiden POASM, Mesyuarat Agung Ke-16, Persatuan Orang Asli Semenanjung Malaysia (POASM) Pada 30 April 2006, Putrajaya, Malaysia: Jawatankuasa POASM.
  • Todd, H., (1990), Stolen Birthright: Orang Asli Rapidly Losing Land, Utusan Konsumer, 206:9-12.
  • WGIP Report, (1996), Report of the Working Group on Indigenous Populations, 14 Session (Geneva, 29 July - 2 August 1996), E/CN4/Sub2/1996/21, 16 August 1996.
  • Whipple, R.T.M., (1997), Assessing Compensation Under the Provisions of the Native Title Act -Part 1 & 2, Native Title News, 3(3): 30-4; 3(4): 49-52.
  • Xanthaki, A., (2003), Land Rights of Indigenous People in South East Asia, Melbourne Journal of International Law, Vol.4, 2003.
  • Yap, M.C., (2002), For a Voice the Orang Asli Can Call Their Own, , surfing on 17 May 2006.
  • Yaqin, A., (2002), Law and Society in Malaysia, Kuala Lumpur: International Law Book Services (ILBS).