Home • PRRES Inc. Journal • Read the Journal

A Comparison of Implicit Values and Explicit Prices of Water

Author/s: Henning Bjornlund, Brian O’Callaghan

Date Published: 1/01/2005

Published in: Volume 11 - 2005 Issue 3 (pages 316 - 331)

Abstract

This paper reviews the historic relationship between the explicit market price of water entitlements and the implicit value of water when attached to land. Hedonic functions are applied to 246 farm sales during 2001–02 in the Greater Shepparton, Campaspe and Moira areas of northern Victoria in order to establish the implicit value of water. These implicit values are then compared to explicit prices paid for water entitlements during the same period. A longitudinal analysis of this relationship is then conducted based on a similar analysis from the same region during the 1991–93 and 1994–96 periods.It was found that during the early to mid 1990’s, the explicit price of water entitlements lagged implicit values as farmers sold unused water which would not compromise the productive capacity of their farms. In 1997, events occurred to push the explicit price above the implicit value during the 1994–96 period. From mid 2002, following a prolonged and increasingly intense drought, the explicit price of water entitlements significantly exceeded the implicit value of water. This caused an increase in the number of land transactions, with many purchasers subsequently selling the attached water entitlements in order to profit from the emerging price gap.

Download Full Article

Download the Full Article PDF

14445921.2005.11104190.pdf 14445921.2005.11104190.pdf (230kB)

Keywords

Water Markets - Water Prices - Water Values

References

  • Belsley, D.A. (1991): Condition Diagnostics. Colinearity and Weak Data in Regression U.U Wiley-Interscience Publication.
  • Bjornlund, H. (2004): Water markets, Water rights and the Environment – What the Irrigation Community Tells Us, Victoria, New South Wales and South Australia. Industry Partner Report written as part of the ARC SPIRT project Draft Final Report Section 3. For a copy contact the author at HTUhenning.bjornlund@unisa.edu.auUTH.
  • Bjornlund, H. (2003a): Farmer Participation in Markets for Temporary and Permanent Water in Southeastern Australia. Agricultural Water Management 63, 57–76.
  • Bjornlund, H. (2003b): Empirical evidence of factors driving prices paid, volumes traded and number of transfers in permanent and temporary markets. Industry Partner Report written as part of the ARC SPIRT project Draft Final Report Section 2. For a copy contact the author at henning.bjornlund@unisa.edu.au.
  • Bjornlund, H. (2002): Signs of Maturity in Australian Water Markets. New Zealand Property Journal July, 31–46.
  • Bjornlund, H. (2001): Water Policies and Rural Land Values. Paper presented at the 7 Pacific Rim Real Estate Society Conference, Adelaide January 21–24, www.business.unisa.edu.au/prres.
  • Bjornlund, H. and O’Callaghan, B. (2004): Property Implications of the Separation of Land and Water Rights. Pacific Rim Property Research Journal 10(1), 54–78.
  • Bjornlund, H. and Shananhan, M. (2005): Tracing the emergence of water markets along the River Murray in Australia. Submitted for publication in the Journal of Law and Economics. For a copy, contact the authors at henning.Bjornlund@unisa.edu.au.
  • Griliches, Z. (1971): Hedonic Price Indexes for Automobiles: An Econometric Analysis of Quality Change. In Griliches, Z. (Ed.) Price Indexes and Quality Change. Studies in New Methods of Measurement. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
  • Crouter, J.P. (1985): An Examination of an Implicit Water Rights Market Using Hedonic Estimation. PhD Economics Thesis, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Urbana, Illinois.
  • Crouter, J. P. (1987): Hedonic Estimation Applied to a Water Rights Market. Land Economics 63(3), 260–271.
  • Dunford, R. W., Marti, C.E., Mittlehammer, R. C. (1985): A Case Study of Rural Land Prices at the Urban Fringe Including Subjective Buyer Expectations. Land Economics 61(1), 10–16.
  • Hartmann, L. M. and Anderson, R. L. (1963): Estimating irrigation water values: A regression analysis of farm sales data from Northeastern Colorado. Agricultural Experiment Station, Colorado State University. Fort Collins, Colorado.
  • Hartman, L.M. and Anderson, R.L. (1962): Estimating the Value of Irrigation Water From Farm Sales Data in Northeastern Colorado. Journal of Farm Economics 44, 207–213.
  • King, D. A. and Sinden, J. A. (1995): Influences of Soil Conservation on Farm Land Values. Land Economics 64 (3), 242–255.
  • Milliman, J. W. (1959): Land Values as Measures of Primary Irrigation Benefits, Journal of Farm Economics 41, 234–43.
  • Renshaw, E. F. (1958): Cross-sectional Pricing in the Market for Irrigated Land. Agricultural Economic Research, January, 17–19.
  • Royer, S.A. (1995): The value of water rights in Southern Alberta: A hedonic price model approach. Unpublished masters thesis, University of Alberta (1995).
  • Summers, L.C. (1981): An Economic Framework for Valuing Trancient Water Rights in the Arid West. The Appraisal Journal, January, 9–14.
  • Xu, F., Mittlehammer, R. and Barkley, P. W. (1993): Measuring the contribution of site characteristics to the value of agricultural land. Land Economics 69(4), 356–69.